I'm joining the conversation now on ribbons, awareness, and such, started by
The Maybe Baby (Babies) and continued by the
Stirrup Queen (and
here), especially after our little get-together for coffee Sunday afternoon. But first, note the disclaimer at the bottom of this post, acknowledging my liberalness, in case you didn't already know.
I don't wear ribbons, not since I wrote my thesis on the message of fear the pi.nk rib.bon movement uses to scare women into medicalizing their bodies and fearing bre.ast can.cer (above all other diseases and conditions) and places a great deal of responsibility on women to prevent a disease that often isn't preventable. I know that one sentence isn't enough to explain my thoughts on this issue, and I hope I haven't offended you here, but that's another post.
I believe in bre.ast can.cer awareness and supporting research to find a cure, but The Maybe Baby (Babies) already asked some good questions here, and I want to talk more about ribbons and symbols in general on this post. Plus, Melissa's already written excellent points on the problems of awareness versus action, with which I whole-heartedly agree. Suffice it to say that I'm not the only critic of the pi.nk rib.bon--my thesis was triggered by the Barbara Ehrenreich article The Maybe Baby (Babies) quoted--and the "culture of pink kitsch. Another great article, "
Think Before You Pink," by Mary Jane Horton, talks about thinking carefully before you donate because proceeds may not be going to bre.ast can.cer research as you'd hoped. For those of you looking for a national organization that pointedly does NOT use the pi.nk rib.bon,
Bre.ast Can.cer Action is a great resource. There's a long list of articles on the problems with the pi.nk rib.bon
here.
Ok, still with me?
Anyway, part of my thesis examined the ribbon as a symbol. I won't go all theoretical and academic here, but suffice it to say that symbols are a powerful thing. And they have a life of their own, that can change. Two examples:
1) Post 9/11, so many Americans--and people from other countries--proudly displayed the American flag to show pride in America (and patriotism), remembrance to those killed on 9/11, and defiance to terrorism. I'd argue that after the years immediately following 9/11, after Bush lost his greatest support from the American public, the American flag quickly became a symbol of political conservatism and support of the Bush administration. I don't know if that's why Obama didn't always wear an American flag pin, but it's my reason, and I wouldn't be surprised if it was his. Two years ago, to me, in a pre-Obama world, it felt like the American flag as a symbol was quickly changing...again though, another post...My point is, the American flag has always been a powerful symbol, and post 9/11, it became an even more powerful symbol as people scrambled for a way to show solidarity and remembrance after our perceptions of the world changed so drastically. The American flag, already powerful, changed quickly not once, but I'd argue twice over the course of about seven years.
2) Our country continues to argue about the display of the confederate flag because as a symbol, it is so powerful. Confederate flag supporters say that it's a symbol of Southern heritage and pride. Others, however, say that as a symbol, it's too closely tied to the Civil war and support of slavery and racism (though I know that wasn't the reason for the Civil War...) that you can't separate the heritage and pride from the symbol. I'd certainly agree...I'm sure some of those supporters aren't racist, but I don't think it's a coincidence that you so often see this symbol aligned with the politically conservative, whose ideals very often don't include human and civil rights for all, whether this time, that discrimination is aimed at gay and lesbian people, or whomever...My point here: the confederate flag was such a powerful symbol that despite the wishes of a minority, the meaning of this symbol has not been effectively changed over time, hence the continued debate about its display.
My point is that symbols are powerful, and individuals can try to change their meaning, and maybe, over time, groups of individuals can change their meaning. With time and history, symbols gain meaning, and regardless of individual intent, symbols mean something.
When I see a yellow ribbon, I feel like I'm hearing "I support our country." But I also feel like I'm hearing "I support(ed) Bush." So, could you sport a yellow ribbon and still think Bush was a horrible president? Many, I believe, would argue no--hence all the bumper stickers about supporting our troops by advocating for peace, or a change of presidential administration and hence a change of war strategy.
When I see a pi.nk rib.bon on a product or used by a corporation, I feel like I'm hearing "I'm good. I support women," with the sub-text being, "You should buy my product over my competitor because I am this way." I believe the pi.nk rib.bon, most of all, has been co-opted by corporations and misused. At this point, what does "bre.ast can.cer awareness" mean? Many have pointed out the problems with the use of the pi.nk rib.bon on products--the fund raising doesn't always go to research, or if it does, it goes to researching only the genetic causes of can.cer, funded by pharmaceutical giants, rather than researching the environmental (and more likely and predominant) causes of cancer.
I don't wear ribbons because while the surface message might seem okay--support this cause--bring research to this cause--remember victims of this cause--so often, there seems to be a subtext with which I cannot align myself. Or the ribbons just don't have quite the right message emphasizing ACTION, as Melissa so aptly explains
here. I've worn the purple ribbon on limited occasions, and then, only as a function of my job at the time, providing crisis intervention to victims of sexual violence.
And I've also got the pomegranate ribbon on my sidebar...which is the REAL reason for this post. As many of you know, "
Infertility's Common Thread" is a form of organized awareness--with strands of pomegranate embroidery thread (#814 from DMC). It's not a ribbon or a rubber bracelet. It's just a homemade solution: a simple piece of embroidery thread tied around your wrist. And it's not about awareness, at least that's not my take on it (though of course, I still believe individual understandings of symbols can't outweigh public understandings of symbols); because it's not well-known, really, it's about letting us infertiles find each other.
I like this idea. I think it's VERY different from ribbons. While I'm all about infertility awareness AND action (as in health care coverage for IVF and fertility medicine for all people), if you aren't from the ALI community, you don't know about this thread, and I'm okay with that. It's a way for us infertiles to recognize each other out in the real world. In a few months, I may be walking around with a pregnant belly (I hope!), but I'll still be wearing my pomegranate thread. For the ALI bloggers who may see me, they'll know that pregnant belly wasn't easy or accidental; they'll know I'm one of them. With or without the pregnant belly, maybe I'll be somewhere and meet an acquaintance I've known for years, but we've never shared our IF struggles. And with the pomegranate thread she or he will know I'm a friend.
I'm very much "out of the closet": with regards to my infertility--I'll tell anyone if/how it comes up in a conversation. I don't think it should be hidden, but the pomegranate thread is a separate thing.
Although, I've only ever met one other person who also wears the pomegranate thread--the Stirrup Queen, and she's the one who inspired me to wear one--I have hope that I will. I have hope that over time, the pomegranate thread will become a powerful symbol among the ALI community. We're not there yet--many people know about it, but so many of us do not wear it, and for good reason too.
Infertility is a private journey, and many of us don't want a public display of it. I've never yet been asked about the thread (well, except for J...and it took him over a month to realize I was wearing it), so for me, it's still a private symbol, but I understand how it isn't something others would want to wear. Maybe someone will someday ask me about it, and in that way, yes, it can serve to raise awareness...I just don't believe that will ever be the primary function of the pomegranate thread.
That's why I wear the pomegranate thread: for those of us who are looking for that "Infertile" "scarlet A" of sorts, so we can find each other in the real world, the pomegranate thread exists. Maybe I'm in a funny place, and maybe it's just because IF is so personal, and thus so important, for me that I'll wear this thread (and I hope it gains traction and power as a symbol among the ALI community), but I won't wear ribbons. Maybe I'm naive in thinking this thread could thrive without being corrupted as an "awareness" symbol, because of it's "in community" nature. But maybe I'm not. For now, I wear the pomegranate thread.
Disclaimer:
*I'm liberal. I believe all people deserve the same human and civil rights. I think we should nationalize health care (but only if our fucked up government could actually do it right, like England, France, Canada...or even Cuba...watch _Sicko_ and you'll know what I mean there...). I think education is the great equalizer, but I think our fucked up education system doesn't give children equal opportunities, and then we can't expect people to "pull themselves up by their bootstraps." I heart Obama. Can I make it more clear where I'm coming from?